Apple has been ordered to leave Unreal Engine and Epic subsidiaries alone
(Image credit: Epic Games)
Apple and Epic Games won’t be going to trial over the Fortnite dispute until next year, but the conflict rages on anyway. Epic’s been trying to get the court to force Apple to reinstate Fortnite on iOS, claiming its banishment is causing irreparable harm, while also trying to stop it from retaliating by blocking the Unreal Engine, a move that would affect a lot of other developers. The request has been successful, in part.
The status quo, with Fortnite barred from iOS, won’t be changing. In August, Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers ruled that Apple didn’t need to let Fortnite return, and none of Epic’s arguments since have convinced her otherwise.
In court documents from October 9 (cheers, The Verge), Epic’s request was called “extraordinary relief,” which isn’t “awarded as of right.” Epic argued that, while it chose to breach its agreement with Apple, the court shouldn’t assist Apple in enforcing a contract that’s “anti-competitive and violative of antitrust laws.”
Since Epic has yet to prove that Apple has violated antitrust laws, its argument wasn’t persuasive, so Fortnite won’t be coming back to Apple devices until one of the companies folds.
“In short,” said Rogers, “Epic Games cannot simply exclaim ‘monopoly’ to rewrite agreements giving itself unilateral benefit. Its other identified bases: damage to its reputation and the Fortnite gaming community cannot constitute irreparable harm where such harm flows from Epic Games’ own actions and its strategic decision to breach its agreements with Apple.”
It’s better news for the Unreal Engine, which Apple sought to remove alongside Fortnite. A temporary restraining order was granted in August, and Rogers believes Epic has shown that Apple’s plans were “retaliatory” and that taking adverse action against its subsidiaries, collectively referred to as Epic Affiliates, would do irreparable harm.
Apple didn’t challenge this, but did argue that it has historically removed affiliated developer accounts and tools in similar circumstances, and that the harm is self-inflicted. Apple also claimed that Epic could put a “secret code” in the Unreal Engine and other Epic apps. Rogers wasn’t convinced, granting Epic’s motion for a preliminary injunction.
So the temporary restraining order has been given an upgrade, ordering Apple to not take action against Epic Affiliates by “restricting, suspending or terminating the Epic Affiliates from the Apple’s Developer Program,” and remaining in effect until there’s an outcome to the litigation.
The trial is set for May 3, 2021, but a pre-trial hearing will take place on October 19.
Fraser is the sole inhabitant of PC Gamer’s mythical Scottish office, conveniently located in his flat. He spends most of his time wrangling the news, but sometimes he sneaks off to write lots of words about strategy games.